“A doctor should never disclose medical information about his patients” What does this statement mean? Argue to the contrary. To what extent do you agree with this statement?
The ethical principle of respecting patients’ autonomy is crucial in maintaining a trustful doctor-patient relationship. On
this
basis, the statement argues that no part of a patient’s medical data or records should be revealed no matter the scenario.
However
, it can be argued that there are certain circumstances where it is necessary to breach patient confidentiality. For instance
, if a patient is suspected of having a communicable disease such
as Covid-19, doctors
are required to immediately alert local health authorities so that precautions can be made to protect others. Besides
, in cases where it is necessary to disclose a patient’s medical information
is when they have broken, or plan to break the law such
as murder.
Nevertheless
, I still agree with the statement to a large extent. That is
, in most cases, patients should have the right to be informed about their medical information
. This
is evident when doctors
disclose a patient’s medical information
without their permission, which could be detrimental to their trust in doctors
. This
could further
result in poor communication and ineffective treatment because doctors
are unable to gain sufficient information
required to diagnose the patient.
In conclusion, a doctor should never disclose medical information
about their patients unless there are circumstances that deem it necessary to do so. However
, in some cases, the decision to disclose medical information
is hard to be determined. Therefore
, such
situations should be decided on a case-by-case basisSubmitted by sumiyoshi912 on
Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Writing9 with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
Your opinion
Don’t put your opinion unless you are asked to give it.
If the question asks what you think, you MUST give your opinion to get a good score.
Don’t leave your opinion until the conclusion.
Here are examples of instructions that require you to give your opinion:
...do you agree or disagree?...do you think...?...your opinion...?