In some countries, criminal trials are shown on television for the public. Do the advantages outweigh the disadvantages?
There are some nations where judicial proceedings of criminal cases are televised.
This
essay shall first
discuss the benefits of this
in the sense that it builds public trust, followed by a problem that it causes around the peace and harmony of the region.
Publicly televised cases of crimes increases the transparency of the courtrooms. Instead
of closed door trials, where people have no clue about what the lawyers are saying, open forums enables them to hear both the sides of the argument. This
impedes the second
hand information being passed to the general public which in turn increases their trust in the justice system. For example
, In USA people believe that the public hearing of senator's confirmation has increased their faith in the authorities.
On the downside, a disadvantage of having open hearings is that people may sometimes disagree with the ruling. Because of this
, their resentment towards courts grows and they lose respect of the lawyers and the judges. Additionally
, when the public does not agree with the court's decision, it can also
lead to protests which can cause civil disobedience and unrest. For instance
, televised decision in a murder case in North Carolina caused a widespread protest last
year.
To sum up, although
having the public listen in on the dealings inside the court help grow a more transparent system, it also
can be potentially dangerous to the peace in the community. In my opinion the benefits that an open door hearing provides is much less appealing due to the grave danger it poses to the community.Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Writing9 with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
Answer the 'Advantages and Disadvantages' topic
IELTS advantages and disadvantages questions normally give you a statement and ask you to comment on the advantages and disadvantages of that statement.
Answer structure for the type of essay
- Introduction
- Body paragraph 1 – advantages
- Body paragraph 2 – disadvantages
- Conclusion
Examples to start your body paragraph:
- The main advantage is...
- The disadvantage of this...
- The main benefit...
- Despite these advantages...
- One possible drawback...