Some people believe that there should be fixed punishments for each type of crime. Others, however, argue that the circumstances of an individual crime, and the motivation for committing it, should always be taken into account when deciding on the punishment. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
There have been different views about how
crime
should be punished. Some people believe that it is better to have a fixed punishment
for all kinds of crimes
. Some others, including me, claim that each crime
should have a different punishment
as it may commit under different circumstances and with different intentions.
Fixed punishment
, on the one hand, can prevent any corruption within the legal system, which can affect the punishment
given. In a corrupt system, money and influence may decide which cases are prioritized or dismissed. As a result
, perpetrators may get away unpunished while
victims are left with no answer or justice. In addition
, fix punishment
can be more deterrent when people know the exact consequences because more people are ignorant about the type of crimes
they commit and their results. Nonetheless
, all of those can be reduced by training. For example
, judicial personnel should be adequately trained and receive fair salaries to make them less vulnerable to bribery. Moreover
, the government can set up some programs to increase society's awareness of the justice system.
On the other hand
, not all crimes
are committed under the same circumstances. Punishment
should fit the crime
and some factors like poverty, mental health, and intention should be taken into account. For example
, a person committing a violent felony with a clear intention should not receive the same punishment
as someone acting in self-defence. Furthermore
, the flexibility of punishment
may decrease the rate of violent crime
, as a violent felony does not receive the same punishment
as a petty crime
. For instance
, drug traffickers may bring more drugs if there is a fixed punishment
because they believe that they will receive the same punishment
for each amount of drug, so they prefer to bring more.
In conclusion, although
fixed punishment
has many benefits, such
as preventing corruption, or it may be more deterrent, I believe that it is better to judge each crime
by its circumstances, which may decrease the rate of violent crimes
.Submitted by ha.mahsa73 on
Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Writing9 with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
Your opinion
Don’t put your opinion unless you are asked to give it.
If the question asks what you think, you MUST give your opinion to get a good score.
Don’t leave your opinion until the conclusion.
Here are examples of instructions that require you to give your opinion:
...do you agree or disagree?...do you think...?...your opinion...?