Under British and Australian laws a jury in a criminal case has no access to information about the defendant's past criminal record. This protects the person who is being accused of the crime. Some lawyers have suggested that this practice should be changed and that a jury should be given all the past facts before they reach their decision about the case. Do you agree or disagree?

People who live under the law of British and Australia often debate regarding the possible
access
to a persons' criminal
records
for
Jury
. Many people suggest that the
Jury
should have the
access
to the criminal
records
of the appellant for a sound
judgment
, whereas, some radical thinkers believe the
access
to the police
records
could deviate the
case
and clouds the
Jury
's
judgment
. I disagree with
this
, a
jury
would able to make a better decision if the past
records
are available. It prevents the criminal to escape from punishment.
To begin
with, the advocates of British and Australian law have argued that the
Jury
has to verify and evaluate each
case
individually. The persons' old
records
should not impact the decision of the Judge and the confidentiality of respondents' details should be preserved. A famous road traffic accident
case
of Mr Roy Johndon in New York, 2015 is a good example of
this
. Having an idea of a person who had minor charges on drunken drive 10 years ago has influenced the
Jury
's
judgment
without verifying the current evidence of drunken drive. Mr John was sentenced to prison for 10 years for a murder charge. The
case
was re-opened after his wife's appeal to the high court where justice is served and he was released. Because the
Jury
had
access
to his old police report, an innocent man has suffered for 3 years in prison.
On the other hand
, scholars in civil administration have said knowing one person's past will aid a better
judgment
during trials. It is quite clear when a criminal investigator was arrested for the rape of a 15-year-old schoolgirl in Sydney in 2018, the
Jury
had delivered a
judgment
based on the current circumstance. The officer was released and he killed the fourth victim while raping at his apartment and the neighbours witnessed the horrifying death of a young girl. There were two other school girls who had complaints against
this
particular officer for rape charges in the past.
However
, there were no data available during the
first
trial, the psychopath officer had his freedom to thrive in his crime. The death of a young girl would have prevented if the system of justice allowed to have the
access
to criminal
records
. In conclusion, In spite of the negative impact that has caused by knowing persons' previous criminal reports, there are greater benefits when serving fair
judgment
.
Therefore
, I strongly disagree with the British and Australian laws where there are no available particulars about the suspect's old crime. The details of the litigant's history are a vital fact when the
Jury
gives the final verdict.

Fully explain your ideas

To get an excellent score in the IELTS Task 2 writing section, one of the easiest and most effective tips is structuring your writing in the most solid format. A great argument essay structure may be divided to four paragraphs, in which comprises of four sentences (excluding the conclusion paragraph, which comprises of three sentences).

For we to consider an essay structure a great one, it should be looking like this:

  • Paragraph 1 - Introduction
    • Sentence 1 - Background statement
    • Sentence 2 - Detailed background statement
    • Sentence 3 - Thesis
    • Sentence 4 - Outline sentence
  • Paragraph 2 - First supporting paragraph
    • Sentence 1 - Topic sentence
    • Sentence 2 - Example
    • Sentence 3 - Discussion
    • Sentence 4 - Conclusion
  • Paragraph 3 - Second supporting paragraph
    • Sentence 1 - Topic sentence
    • Sentence 2 - Example
    • Sentence 3 - Discussion
    • Sentence 4 - Conclusion
  • Paragraph 4 - Conclusion
    • Sentence 1 - Summary
    • Sentence 2 - Restatement of thesis
    • Sentence 3 - Prediction or recommendation

Our recommended essay structure above comprises of fifteen (15) sentences, which will make your essay approximately 250 to 275 words.

Read more in the eBook

The Ultimate Guide to Get a Target Band Score of 7+ »

* free ebook for Premium users

Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Writing9 with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

What to do next:
Try other services:

All the services are free for Premium users