In A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens, tensions are rising throughout the book between the
Estate and the
and
Estate.
eventually led up to the French
, a ten-year struggle for power, where French commoners rose and challenged the monarchy in place.
was due to how poorly the
Estate was treated, which made it seem as if
is necessary. Once the French
breaks out, the revolutionaries go on a killing spree, as they start to lose their
on what they are fighting for. Even though the violence of the revolutionaries escalated out of control and clouded their vision of righteousness, the French
was ultimately justified because of how poorly and cruelly the 3rd Estate was being treated by the
.
Though the revolutionaries committed various acts that were deemed immoral and unrighteous, the
is justified because of how awful the 1st and 2nd Estate treated the 3rd Estate before the
. The revolutionaries may have committed immoral acts to the
because of their
for
, like killing the prisoners in mass, but since the upper classes committed worse acts towards the 3rd Estate, the
is justified. In Chapter 7 of the
book, the Marquis gets angry after he does not get what he wants, so he orders his carriage to drive down the village roads fast, making people scramble for their lives. The carriage proceeds to turn a corner where a fountain is, and when doing so, “one of its wheels [comes] to a sickening jolt, and there [is] a loud cry from a number of voices,” (Dickens 111). After the Marquis realizes he had just run over a
, he scolds the peasants for not taking care of themselves.
justifies the revolt that stopped the cruel actions by the
from continuing.
, another action that was deemed cruel was that of Foulon, a member of the
who had faked his death. When tasked with the problem of starving commoners, Foulon proceeded to “[tell] the famished people that they [should] eat grass,” (Dickens 219).
action caused an increase in tensions between the upper and lower class and was ultimately justified when Foulon was killed and beheaded by the revolutionaries, but the revolutionaries go a little overboard by shoving Foulon’s mouth with grass. Due to
, the 3rd Estate was seen as violent and out of control, losing
of the
they fought hard for;
, the
was justified because of Foulon’s actions towards the commoners.
, the
was ultimately justified because the
thought they could solve all of their mishaps and problems by simply giving money for the unlawful acts committed against the poor;
causing tension between the
and the 3rd Estate over time. Whenever there was an issue with the 3rd Estate, the
thought and believed that they could easily solve the problem by throwing money at the commoners. Before Doctor
is imprisoned, he is taken in by the Evremonde brothers to help a woman, and when Doctor
realizes what they did to her and her family he is in shock. The
day, when Doctor
opens his door, a “‘
of
was left on [his] door in a little box, with [his] name on the outside,’” (Dickens 327). The
rouleauthe actions and activities assigned to or required or expected of a person or group
of
on his doorstep was a bribe from the Evermonde brothers to keep
’s mouth shut, and when
eventually does tell the authorities, he is thrown in prison.
action
exemplifies that the
was justified, because of the 3rd Estate’s unfair treatment. Another example of the 3rd Estate’s maltreatment is when the Marquis throws a
at the father after running over the
. In Chapter 7, just after the Marquis runs over Gaspard’s
and scolds the people, the Marquis thinks he can make up for the
’s loss by simply throwing a
at the
’s father. The Marquis does not feel bad whatsoever, he just “[throws] out a
for the valet to pick up” (Dickens 111), which causes Gaspard to seek
and go kill the Marquis. The killing of the
by the Marquis shows how the
was justified because commoners like Gaspard wanted
against the
for actions like
. The commoners were being treated as dogs
of real people as they are being thrown “treats” for whenever the
does something to them that harms them. The throwing of the
from the Marquis is an example of how the
uses their wealth to solve all of their problems;
causing the people to want to revolt because the
thought of the commoners as items, rather than real people.
Though there are many reasons why the
is unjustified due to the clouded vision of the revolutionaries, there are more examples that prove that the
is justified. Over the course of the French
, the revolutionaries lost
of what they were aiming for, which was
, and they
sought to execute anyone who opposed the
.
,
the time before the
showed, the revolutionaries had some reason to be as crazed and
blood-thirstymarked by eagerness to resort to violence and bloodshed
they were, because of their poor treatment. Since the 3rd Estate was treated so poorly, the commoners were forced to go crazy and hellish because of all of their built-up anger and suffering. Overall, the
is ultimately seen as justified because of the unjust treatment of the commoners due to the spoiled aristocrats.