Some people believe that there should be fixed punishment for each type of crime. Others argue that the circumstances of an individual’s crimes and the motivation for committing it should always be taken into account when deciding on the punishment. Discuss both views, give your opinions.

People are divided into two groups when it comes to the punishing frame for offenders. While many people believe that there should be different fixed punishments depending on each type of

crime

, others argue that it is necessary to take into account the background and motive for the

crime

before giving the final sentences. In my opinion, I side with the statement that fixed

punishment

for individual

crimes

is the most suitable and efficient rule. The essay will analyze both sides of

this

view before clarifying the conclusion. On the one hand, personal circumstances and motivation for

crime

are considered as adding elements when deciding

punishment

.

For example

, in a scandalous Chinese family assault case in which the husband, Li Fan, constantly hit his wife to death, escaped the

punishment

due to his psychological certification leading to his uncontrollable behaviours, according to Chinese law.

This

means that both external and internal factors have certain effects on a trial’s final decision. Despite the fact that the

crime

’s background and motive can help bring justice to legitimate cases,

this

may lead to the propensity to use special circumstances as a shield to reduce the

punishment

.

Thus

,

this

makes it hard to support.

On the other hand

, it is argued that fixed

punishment

is crucial depending on the various kinds of

crime

.

For instance

, Vietnamese criminal law clarifies that minor

crimes

,

such

as shoplifting or pickpocketing, are sent to prison, while serious

crimes

,

such

as murder or drug trading, are sent for life, or even receive the death penalty.

This

not only gives people who commit minor

crimes

a

second

chance to habilitate and reintegrate into society but

also

avoids serious

crime

from creating a criminal culture, particularly among the young. It can be seen that it is essential to establish

punishment

for detailed offences. In conclusion,

although

many think that considering motivation for committing a

crime

and other factors is needed for a final decision, I strongly believe that fixed punishments are better measures to maintain social security.