In recent years, the question of whether crimes should be judged solely on the basis of the act itself has sparked a contentious debate.
While
some people contend that a predetermined penalty for each category of offence ensures consistency and fairness in sentencing, others argue that the intention and motives of the accused must Linking Words
also
be taken into account in court to achieve justice. Linking Words
Although
both perspectives have merit, I firmly support the latter viewpoint.
On the one hand, some individuals argue that fixed punishments ensure consistency and Linking Words
therefore
act as a strong deterrent. If potential offenders consider committing unlawful acts, Linking Words
such
as armed robbery, arson, or even murder, each of which carries a specific sentence, they may think twice before acting impulsively. Linking Words
For instance
, since Saudi Arabia has maintained the death penalty for all individuals convicted of murder, regardless of motive, it has recorded one of the lowest homicide rates in the world. Linking Words
Furthermore
, fixed penalties can significantly reduce bias and corruption, as judicial rulings are less likely to be influenced by public pressure or discrimination, thereby ensuring greater fairness.
Linking Words
On the other hand
, I agree with those who emphasise the importance of considering an offender's circumstances and background before deciding on a punishment. To illustrate Linking Words
this
, it is unreasonable to treat two thieves identically when one stole food to feed a starving child, whilst the other acted purely out of greed; it is morally unjust to impose a similar sentence on both. Linking Words
Accordingly
, if flexible sentencing takes into account factors, including intent, mental health, and socio-economic background, the judicial system can deliver fairer outcomes and promote more effective rehabilitation.
Linking Words
To conclude
, I acknowledge that predictable sentences can serve as a deterrent to crime. Linking Words
However
, I totally believe that true fairness is achievable only through adaptable verdicts, particularly taking into consideration the underlying motives behind an offence.Linking Words